New Jersey: Say No to Surveillance of Homeschool Families
Our Stand: At-A-Glance
- S1796, sponsored by Senator Angela V. McKnight (D–Hudson, District 31) imposes new reporting requirements on homeschool families despite no evidence of a problem that needs solving. This bill is a clear attempt to enact unnecessary government overreach. Bill S1796 is being heard Thursday, June 5th at 11 AM in the Senate Education Committee.
- This bill violates family privacy: it requires parents to disclose personally identifiable information (full name, birth date, and grade level of each child) without any privacy protections.
- It opens the door to Health surveillance: Families who homeschool for health freedom or medical autonomy could face future monitoring or mandates tied to submitted data.
- Creates risk for law-abiding families: Parents who provide quality education but make minor paperwork mistakes could be subjected to legal consequences or harassment.
- Adds bureaucratic burden without benefit: The bill would force public school administrators to process up to 50,000 notices annually, diverting resources from actual student support.
- Threatens New Jersey’s strong legal precedent: Current law requires homeschool education to be equivalent to public school instruction. It works. No new legislation is needed.
- Could lead to future mandates or redefinitions: The term “home-school” is not defined in NJ law, leaving it open to judicial interpretation or further legislative restrictions later.
- Unnecessary burden on state resources – NJ school districts are already overburdened with their own charge of providing proper, quality education that is challenging for most.. They are in no position to oversee a homeschool registry.
- Government overreach – Homeschooling parents are exercising their full parental rights and are in no need to be databased, inspected by the state.
- New Jersey is not an outlier: At least 17 states, including Illinois, Michigan, Texas, and Indiana, require no notice or registration for homeschooling.
- Homeschoolers perform well without red tape: Decades of research confirm that homeschool students meet or exceed academic outcomes compared to public school peers—even in low-regulation states.
- Freedom Works. Bureaucracy Doesn’t: More government control does not produce better results—it produces fear, confusion, and unintended harm for responsible families.
- ACTION: Email both your Senator and the Senate Education Committee and let them know that your homeschool data is not for sale.