Full Story:
The Pennsylvania Department of Health is proposing an extensive rewrite of 28 Pa. Code Chapter 27, the regulations governing communicable and noncommunicable diseases. And when we say extensive, we mean over 500 pages worth of changes.
These regulations are proposed; they are not final. Pennsylvanians have until September 21, 2026 to submit public comments.
Why should Pennsylvanians be concerned?
These new regulations were released for public review and comment at the beginning of August, and as soon as we found out about them, PCIC volunteer advocates began working through the 500+ pages of regulations. With the added news of “two measles-associated deaths” that our PA Department of Health (PA DOH) released this week, we feel an additional sense of urgency to make sure people are aware of the changes the PA DOH is proposing through the regulatory board which bypasses the general assembly.
While some portions of Chapter 27 need to be updated, this proposal would also expand government authority over schools, students, medical records, health surveillance, vaccination information, and access to education.
Public health authority must be clearly defined and accompanied by due process, privacy protections, parental safeguards, and meaningful accountability.
Many are referring to these proposed changes as 2020 era draconian measures but worse. Keep reading for just a few of the changes.
- Expanded disease-control authority: Proposed § 27.60 would allow the Department to use “any other disease control measure” for the broad purposes of “prevention, containment or mitigation” of disease. PADOH specifically explains that this change was influenced by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court’s decision striking down the statewide school masking order in Corman v. Acting Secretary. The proposal does not establish clear severity thresholds, time limits, geographic limits, least-restrictive-means requirements, or legislative oversight for exercising this authority.
- Measures beyond isolation and quarantine: The proposal discusses disease-control measures beyond traditional isolation and quarantine, including social distancing and restricting access to locations. These measures could affect schools, businesses, places of worship, public gatherings, and other aspects of daily life. Terms such as “prevention” and “mitigation” are broad enough to allow government action before an emergency has been formally declared.
- Expansion to “conditions,” toxins, and unusual occurrences: Throughout the proposal, DOH authority applies not only to communicable diseases and infections but also to “conditions,” toxins, public-health emergencies, and “unusual occurrences.” The proposal does not always provide clear definitions or thresholds explaining when these broader categories justify government intervention.
- Government access to students at school: New § 27.60c would require schools to provide health officials reasonable and timely access to students for contact tracing or “partner services,” including while classes are in session or during school functions. School officials would be required to permit health authorities to meet and speak privately with a student and not interfere with rights available under Pennsylvania’s minor-consent statute.
- The regulation does not clearly require advance parental notice, parental consent, a parent’s presence, or notification after the interview. Parents should know when government officials privately question their children about medical, personal, or potentially sexual-health information.
- Expanded school exclusions: The proposal significantly expands and reorganizes the conditions under which students, staff members, and others may be excluded from schools and child care settings. For certain diseases, DOH could exclude people considered “susceptible” until they provide proof that they are not susceptible, receive a vaccination, or the specified outbreak period passes.
- Some outbreak-exclusion authority already exists. The concern is whether the proposed expansions provide adequate recognition of existing exemptions, individualized review, due process, educational continuity, and reasonable alternatives for students who are healthy but considered susceptible.
- Expanded access to medical records: Proposed § 27.60e expressly states that DOH or a local health authority shall have access to patient medical records during an investigation, may request copies, and may require electronic transmission in a manner acceptable to the agency.
- The regulation does not clearly limit requests to the minimum information necessary or require that unrelated sensitive information be excluded. It also lacks detailed statewide standards governing patient notice, data retention, secondary use, security, and destruction of copied records.
- Mandatory emergency-department surveillance: Hospitals currently participate voluntarily in Pennsylvania’s syndromic surveillance system. Proposed § 27.4a would make reporting mandatory and require emergency-department visit data to be submitted as close to real time as possible, but no later than 24 hours after a patient arrives.
- The required information would include diagnoses, symptoms, test orders and results, disposition, and other health information. The proposal would also allow DOH to demand “other data elements deemed necessary” without identifying those additional elements in the regulation. At a time when data privacy is becoming harder and harder to maintain, Pennsylvanians deserve clear limits on what information may be collected, whether it is identifiable, how long it is retained, and how it may be used.
- Mandatory immunization-system participation: The proposal would change participation in Pennsylvania’s immunization information system from voluntary to mandatory for health care practitioners and facilities unless a patient declines reporting in writing.
- This is an opt-out system. Patients’ vaccination information may be reported unless they know about the database and affirmatively decline in writing. The regulation should require clear notice before reporting and explain who may access the information, how long it will be retained, whether previously reported information can be removed, and whether declining may affect access to care.
- Removal of a religious-treatment protection: Existing § 27.87(c) recognizes certain treatment through prayer or spiritual means when sanitation, isolation, and quarantine requirements are followed. PADOH proposes to delete that provision and states that it would recognize religious or spiritual treatment only to the extent it is “evidence-based.”
- The existing accommodation does not excuse someone from measures intended to protect other people. Removing it raises serious religious-liberty concerns and deserves a full analysis under Pennsylvania’s Religious Freedom Protection Act.
What can you do?
SUBMIT A PUBLIC COMMENT
If you’ve read through all of that and you’re motivated to take action, you CAN from the comfort of your couch. Submit a public comment before September 21, 2026 by emailing the Pennsylvania Department of Health (details and email address below)!
- You do not have to be an attorney, physician, or policy expert to comment.
- You may comment as a parent, grandparent, health professional, taxpayer, business owner, patient, or concerned Pennsylvania resident.
- You may address one issue or several.
- Personal, individually written comments are especially valuable.
Comments may be emailed to both the PA Department of Health AND the Independent Regulatory Review Commission (IRRC).
Pennsylvania Department of Health: RA-DHCHAPTR27PROPREG@pa.gov
Independent Regulatory Review Commission: IRRC@IRRC.state.pa.us
Suggested subject line:
PUBLIC COMMENT—Regulation #10-242 / IRRC #3490
Important: Comments submitted during the regulatory process may become part of the public record. DO NOT include private medical information or other personal details you do not want made public.
Points to consider:
- The proposal raises questions about:
- Broad disease-control powers based on suspected illness or exposure
- Access to students during disease investigations without clearly stated parental safeguards
- Exclusion of children from school and the scope of Department authority
- Access to medical information and expanded reporting requirements
- New authority involving animals, food products, property, and suspected contamination
- Removal of an existing religious accommodation for spiritual treatment
- Expanding the discretion of unelected officials without sufficiently clear limits or oversight
Your public comment can be as long or as short as you would like. Some people are commenting simply that they disagree while others are including a reason or two. Use the ideas above to help get you started and flesh out your own comment! You can also find the comments already published on the IRRC’s website if you’re a curious mind.
Need help or want to know more about these proposed regulations?
Watch PCIC’s presentation here to explain the proposed changes, answer common questions, and help Pennsylvanians submit effective comments.
TAG YOUR LEGISLATORS AND THOSE RUNNING FOR OFFICE
When you see PCIC posting about this topic or even other groups posting related content, tag legislators and those running for office (like Stacy Garrity). This is a quick and easy way to get their attention on a matter.
CALL YOUR PA STATE SENATOR AND STATE REPRESENTATIVE
While more and more republican legislators are picking up on these proposed regulation changes, YOUR state senator and representative need to hear that YOU are concerned about these changes, too! Pick up the phone and call BOTH your Pennsylvania State Senator and Pennsylvania State Representative.
Tell their offices: “I’m calling about PA DOH Regulation #10-242, IRRC #3490, concerning proposed changes to Chapter 27. Have you reviewed this proposed regulation, and what are you going to do to protect Pennsylvanians’ parental rights, medical privacy, due process and individual liberties during the regulatory review process?”
You can ask:
- Will you or your committee submit formal comments on this regulation?
- Will you ask PADOH to explain and justify the expansion of its disease-control authority?
- Will you oppose provisions you believe grant overly broad authority?
- Will you keep your constituents informed as this regulation moves through the review process?
If you need help finding your legislator, check HERE.
Spread the word using our social media toolkit:
- Facebook: www.facebook.com/share/p/1DMkio7thr/

