Tell Your Officials To Say No To Mandating The CDC’s COVID-19 School Guidelines. They’re Not Evidence-Based And They Hurt Students And Learning!
- The Illinois State Board of Education is in the process of planning and implementing their statewide recommendations for opening schools in the fall.
- In May 2020, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) released a 60-page document with guidance and initiatives for opening America up again. The document provides detailed guidelines for keeping communities safe and resuming peer-to-peer learning. The CDC also published information on its website outlining ways in which schools can help protect students, teachers, administrators and staff to slow the spread of COVID-19.
- The CDC is advising schools, in collaboration with state and local health officials, to determine “whether and how to implement these considerations while adjusting to meet the unique needs and circumstances of the local community.” The agency’s numerous recommendations and guidelines include:
- Mandatory masks or cloth face coverings for anyone over the age of two, including special needs students and those with IEPs.
- Maintaining adequate distance on school buses, with one child per seat and every other row occupied.
- Staggered school arrival and departure times for students to limit exposure to other peers.
- One-way routes in hallways as well as tape on sidewalks and walls to ensure that kids stay six feet apart.
- Daily health and temperature checks.
- Avoiding personal contact with others (such as shaking hands, holding hands, hugging or kissing).
- Placing desks six feet apart and having all desks face the same direction.
- Installing sneeze guards and partitions wherever desks can’t be spaced six feet apart.
- No sharing of any items or supplies, with all belongings placed in individual cubbies or labeled containers (this means no sharing of electronic devices, toys, games, learning aids, etc.).
- No communal shared spaces such as cafeterias, playgrounds, etc., which would mean no recess or sports.
- Physical barriers or screens placed between sinks in bathrooms.
- Only pre-packaged boxes or bags of food instead of cafeteria food; children are to eat meals in their classrooms.
- No field trips, assemblies or external organizations in the schools; volunteers and visitors will be limited.
- The same children will stay with the same staff all day. There will be no switching groups or teachers. (This means that children will not be able to utilize specialists and switch from their home room to the art room, music room, library, etc.).
- Frequent hand washing by students and staff throughout the day.
- Increased cleaning, disinfecting and ventilating of school facilities throughout the day.
- According to the World Health Organization, the spread and transmission of the coronavirus from an asymptomatic carrier is “rare.” Additionally, children are not at high risk from COVID-19 and it’s generally much less severe — and common — for this age group. As such, the current data does not merit the dramatic response being proposed for schools.
- The Illinois Department of Public Health generally follows the CDC’s guidelines. If the State of Illinois adheres to the CDC’s COVID-19 guidelines/considerations, it will add significant financial burdens to our schools while creating an environment that’s damaging to both students and teachers.
- It’s time to make your voice heard! Take action TODAY by sending a pre-drafted, customizable email to your elected officials, including U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos and the Illinois State Board of Education and its superintendent, Carmen Ayala. When you are done, please share this important campaign with your friends, family and neighbors.
Your home address information is required from the legislative offices to ensure you are reaching out to your designated representatives. Your email and your phone number are used to establish connection with your designated representatives. Messages from non-constituents don't have the same impact on a legislator as messages from verified constituents, who can vote for that officeholder. We do not share your name and contact information with any third parties unless legally required to do so.
Have a question or need help?
Call To Action
Parents have profound concerns over the guidance, initiatives and considerations for opening schools published by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in May 2020. Very simply, they create a restricted learning environment that promotes isolation of children from their peers while forcing healthy individuals to wear a mask. Implementing these recommendations would not only destroy schools financially, it would prevent special needs programs from effectively providing services. Autism-related programs where children need to be encouraged to interact with others will not be able to operate with social distancing measures in place. Services such as speech therapy and occupational therapy would be greatly impacted by an inability to see the movement of the mouth or to physically guide a student for fine motor instruction. Social distancing and wearing cloth face coverings day-in and day-out, especially for all younger children in their formative years, will leave psychological and social damage that will undoubtedly last for years.
Furthermore, these measures will cause families who are unwilling to expose their children to these forms of social isolation to consider homeschooling or to leave their employment to support their child’s educational needs. A loss of enrollment will cause further financial loss to our schools, which have already taken a blow from the economic shutdown.
Most importantly, to date there are no studies or cases of documented asymptomatic transmission of COVID-19, and the World Health Organization recently confirmed that asymptomatic transmission is “rare.” It has also been noted that children and individuals outside of at-risk categories have little to no chance of risk from COVID-19 complications. The latest data demonstrates that the COVID-19 case fatality rate is at 0.26%, which is akin to a bad seasonal flu — and significantly below the original estimates of a 4% to 10% fatality rate (source: https://tinyurl.com/y7ebjnvn).
In her June 18, 2020 ‘Update to Schools’ letter, Illinois State Superintendent of Education Dr. Carmen Ayala stated (source: https://tinyurl.com/y8crebbd), “Having been a district superintendent in Illinois, I understand the urgency of getting clarity and direction out to all of you as quickly as possible. At the same time, the stakes have never been higher for our guidance to adhere to the best and most current science and data. Meeting this standard has meant deep collaboration with public health experts.”
However, the Illinois Department of Public Health and the Office of the Governor have not confirmed and have been unable to produce ANY findings from the CDC to support the theory that (a) healthy people wearing cloth face coverings prevents the spread of illness; (b) forced separation of individuals slows transmission; and (c) asymptomatic transmission of illness occurs. In other words, there is NO evidence or scientific data to support that the CDC and the Illinois Department of Public Health have based their guidelines on science or medical evidence. Thus, these guidelines/considerations, on which Governor Pritzker and the Illinois State Board of Education are basing their guidance, are founded on inconclusive assumptions with NO reputable peer-reviewed studies to support them.
Clearly, the data that is now available does not merit the dramatic response being proposed for schools.
It’s time to make your voice heard now! Take action below by emailing your elected officials, including the U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos and the Illinois State Board of Education and its Superintendent, Dr. Carmen Ayala. Let them know that the CDC’s guidelines are not evidence-based and hurt learning.
If you have a personal perspective to share as a teacher, student, parent or concerned citizen, please add it to the top section above the provided message. You can also edit the subject line and the pre-drafted message as needed. Additionally, if these measures would cause you to pull your child from the Illinois school system — or if you are a school employee considering leaving your position as a result of the measures — be sure to mention that in your message.
Note: For more detailed information, please consult: